Petplan vs Direct Line pet insurance
Last updated
Two of the best-known names in UK pet insurance, but built around different ideas. Petplan is the heritage specialist that has done pet cover and only pet cover since 1976. Direct Line is the household multi-line insurer that does cars, homes, pets and life under one roof. The right answer depends on whether you want depth or breadth.
Quick verdict
For owners who want the deepest cover, the broadest vet-practice recognition and the option to insure a senior pet from scratch, Petplan is the better product even at a small premium. For existing Direct Line customers who value bundling and a familiar single insurer, Direct Line is a credible mainstream option, provided the standalone quote stacks up against alternatives.
Side-by-side
| Brand | Petplan | Direct Line |
|---|---|---|
| PetCoverPro score | 4.4 / 5 | 3.9 / 5 |
| Cover style | Lifetime | Lifetime |
| Plan tiers | Essential, Classic, Ultimate | Essential, Plus |
| Vet-fee limit | Up to £12,000 per year on Ultimate | Up to £8,000 per year on Plus |
| Excess from | From £99 | From £99 |
| Dental cover | Yes | Partial |
| Behavioural cover | Yes | Partial |
| Mobile app | Yes | No |
| Direct vet payment | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-pet discount | 10% off each additional pet | Multi-product discount across Direct Line policies |
| Max new-policy age | No upper age limit at sign-up | 8 years for dogs and cats |
| Underwriter | Allianz Insurance plc | U K Insurance Limited (Direct Line Group) |
| Get a quote | Visit Petplan → | Visit Direct Line → |
Limits and prices change. Confirm current figures on each brand\u2019s site before buying. We last refreshed this table at the date stamped on the page.
Winner by criterion
Vet-practice familiarity
PetplanPetplan is the most widely recognised UK pet insurer at practice reception desks.
Cover breadth at the top tier
PetplanPetplan Ultimate is one of the broadest mainstream UK products on dental and behavioural.
No upper age limit at sign-up
PetplanPetplan writes new lifetime cover at any age. Direct Line caps new policy entry by species.
Bundled-with-other-cover convenience
Direct LineExisting Direct Line car or home customers get genuine multi-product convenience.
Brand familiarity
TieBoth are household UK insurance names with strong consumer recall.
Headline price
Direct Line (slight)Direct Line is usually a touch cheaper than Petplan on like-for-like lifetime quotes, but rarely by a lot.